College of Education > News and Publications > News: Oct. - Dec. 2011 > Open Letters by Faculty of the College of Education, Penn State

Open Letters by Faculty of the College of Education, Penn State

Bernard BadialiNovember 9, 2011

Dear Students of the Penn State College of Education:

One message we come to understand as we mature and grow into the teaching profession is that “life is for learning.” The message can be phrased many different ways; we say “lifelong learning” or “learning from your experience,” or “becoming a reflective practitioner.” Our whole tradition of reflection in your preparation program is essentially that we should try to think deeply about what our observations and experiences really mean. Through our classes and activities in the College we are always urging you to look beneath the surface, try to make sense of what is going on, and use that knowledge to inform the way we act and think in the future. This way of seeing the world implies that we must give extra effort to understanding human nature as well as human actions. It is not an easy habit to maintain, but it is a habit of mind that is essential if you intend to be a great teacher.

Human events can sometimes be terribly complicated and difficult to understand. What complicates matters is that we are more than just thinking beings; we are also feeling beings. I can remember only a few times in my life where thoughts and feelings have come together so strongly as they have this week. Maybe you share my sense of sadness, shame, anger, and grief for what has come to light at Penn State these past few weeks, or maybe you have other thoughts and feelings about the circumstance we find ourselves in at the moment. Whatever your reaction to this tragedy, I hope you ask yourself three important questions:

  • What did I learn?
  • What does it mean?
  • How can I use it to inform my own life?


Let me just give you a brief personal reaction to these questions. I don’t expect your answers to these questions to be the same as mine, nor is what I am about to write comprehensive enough to express my total reaction to this situation. But it’s a start. If you want to discuss the matter further, I am more than willing to meet and talk with you. I’m sure that your other professors, instructors, and counselors are as well.

What did I learn? I guess I learned that there truly is evil and sickness in the world that I would rather not have known about. I still cannot believe that child abuse of this nature happens and that it could happen right next door. I learned that shock and fear has the power to prevent us from doing the right thing, even when we know we should. I learned that there are always outsiders quick to condemn and cast blame even when they don’t know the facts; people are quick to judge. I learned that sometime the most righteous indignation comes from critics who have never really done anything with their own lives but criticize others. My goodness, how can some loud-mouthed sports reporters tear into the reputation and character of a coach who has given so much for so long to so many? I learned to never doubt the power of community. Good or bad, we are all connected.

What does this mean? It means that even the best of people can suffer a mental illness or be driven by an insidious aspect of their character. It means that power can be very abusive. It means that doing the right things can sometimes take enormous courage. It means to me that compassion and forgiveness are in short supply when outrage is in the air. But it also means that our community sensibilities are to safeguard and protect children who are helpless and to transgress against defenseless kids may be the most unforgivable of crimes. I learned that the law is not the final word when it comes to justice. There are ethical principles beyond the law that better define what is right and what is wrong.

How will I use this to inform my own life? I suppose I will try to have a sharper eye when considering what might be an abuse of power on any level. The words “social justice” have a deeper meaning for me now. I’d like to be more thoughtful and less quick to judge others. That doesn’t mean I won’t judge others. It does mean that I have to be more conscious about what information informs my judgment. This situation also reminds me that we can be loyal to an institution, but that we cannot expect any loyalty in return if we mess up. Do I love Penn State, or do I love the spirit embodied in how Penn Staters relate to one another?

I have also been thinking more about the words of Parker Palmer: “Your life is your message.” If that’s so, then I’d like to thank Joe for living his life with us here at Penn State. Even the best people mess up. I want to work harder on trying to forgive his mistakes as well as the more egregious mistakes of others. That will take some effort in this situation. I want also to keep in mind that I am (we are) Penn State and that our collective goodness will far outdistance the evil that has occurred here.

Thanks for choosing to become a teacher.

Bernard Badiali
Associate Professor of Curriculum and Instruction


Spencer G. Niles

November 21, 2011

The Penn State community has been rocked by tragic allegations of the worst kind. Our collective hearts, thoughts, and prayers go out to victims of sexual abuse in our community and in every community.

The allegations have exposed locally what is a global issue that needs serious and immediate attention by all of us. One out of 4 girls and 1 out of 6 boys are sexually abused.

One out of 20 cases are reported. These are sobering statistics that serve as a call to action for all of us. This exposure has led Penn State to take real and serious steps to raise awareness and take appropriate action. This work will be ongoing.

Many within the Penn State community, myself included, have also found aspects of the media coverage to be disturbing. On one level, it has distracted attention from where it can be most useful (focusing on the issue of pedophilia) to where it can make the most "noise" (e.g., the reactions of a very small percentage of students to board of trustees’ decisions). I use the word "noise" because when I asked a national reporter why he didn't cover the candlelight vigil held to focus attention on the issue of child molestation, his response was that events of that kind don't make enough "noise" to become headlines—despite the fact that 10,000 people attended this event.

As a professor, I am witnessing the demoralization of good people who had absolutely nothing to do with the current situation. Concern for one group does not lessen concern for another. We remain concerned first and foremost for the alleged victims. At the same time, I have concern for members of the Penn State community who are struggling to sort out feelings of pride in their university and in their work when many in the media and public consider the entire community to be guilty by virtue of enrollment or employment.

The acts of a few do not define the character of the many. And, I am proud of our many students, faculty, staff, and administrators who care deeply about doing good work the right way. I am also confident that our community is committed to becoming an even more compassionate university dedicated to academic and moral excellence. The list of accomplishments and good work performed by Penn State students, faculty, staff, and the more than 500,000 alumni is endless.

In the meantime, there are many opinions that have already been formed about the allegations, and, at this point, there are relatively few facts that have been revealed. Until the judicial process is completed, it is inappropriate to comment on the case. All people (the accused and those making the allegations) are entitled to a fair trial without prejudgment. And, on every day and in every location, our children are entitled to safety, care, and protection.

Perhaps this is a good time for everyone to remember and recommit to these values.

Spencer G. Niles
Distinguished Professor of Counselor Education